PRA consultation (CP12/25) Pillar 2A review – Phase 1 Innovate Finance response

12th September 2025 | Consultation

About Innovate Finance

Innovate Finance is the independent industry body that represents and advances the global FinTech community in the UK. Innovate Finance’s mission is to accelerate the UK's leading role in the financial services sector by directly supporting the next generation of technology-led innovators.

The UK FinTech sector covers businesses from seed-stage start-ups to global financial institutions that embrace digital solutions, playing a critical role in technological change across the financial services industry. FinTech has grown enormously since the Global Financial Crisis of 2007/8, which led to mistrust in traditional banks and coincided with an explosion in the use of smartphones, widespread adoption of the use of apps, the advent of blockchain technology, and significant investment in FinTech start-ups.

FinTech is synonymous with delivering transparency, innovation and inclusivity to financial services. In addition to creating new businesses and new jobs, it has fundamentally improved the ways in which consumers and businesses, especially small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs), access financial services.

We represent most of the UK’s digital-first and digital-only challenger banks, all of whom hold a UK banking licence.

  1. Response to consultation1.1 Innovate Finance welcomes the opportunity to respond to Phase 1 of the Prudential Regulation Authority’s (PRA) consultation (CP12/25) on Pillar 2A. In preparing this submission, we have engaged with a cross-section of our membership, including start-up and scale-up challenger banks.

1.2 We have grouped our comments into two main sections: credit risk and operational risk. Given the risk profiles of our members’ business models, our response does not comment on proposals for pension obligation risk, market and counterparty risk.

1.3 Our third section on Supervisory Review and Evaluation Process (SREP) reflects an overarching request from our members for more granular PRA guidance on its expectations for banks’ assessments of Pillar 2A capital. This seems essential given the importance of a consistent approach across the diverse business models of the challenger bank industry.

 

  • Credit Risk2.1 IRB Benchmarking

 

2.2 Some of our members support removing the internal ratings-based (IRB) benchmarking methodology on the basis that it was not sufficiently granular for some key asset classes, such as SME lending. However, others would prefer IRB benchmarking to be retained and enhanced to be more compatible with the needs of challenger bank asset portfolios.

2.3 The difference between IRB and Standardised Approach (SA) calculations of risk weighted assets (RWAs) has narrowed under Basel 3.1 but can still be material for some asset classes, for example, for mortgage portfolios. Removing the benchmarking methodology is therefore likely to place challengers at a competitive disadvantage to larger incumbents

2.4 Retention of benchmarking combined with greater granularity would enable challenger banks’ Pillar 2A credit risk calculations to better reflect nuances in business models. For example, improved benchmarks that distinguish RWA within retail and SME exposures, particularly between secured and unsecured commercial lending, would enable challenger bank SME capital requirements to better reflect their risk profiles.

2.5 We recommend that the PRA provides additional detail in their cost benefit analysis regarding the removal of IRB benchmarking to address the above points. Currently, the analysis considers the cost for larger firms from continuing benchmarking but does not consider the benefits foregone for smaller firms.

2.6 SME support factor

2.7 We welcome the inclusion of an adjustment in Pillar 2A to restore the benefit of the SME support factor that has been removed in Pillar 1. The proposed methodology is straightforward and practical.

2.8 However, we note that the discount applies to the Total Capital Ratio rather than Common Equity Tier 1 (CET1) ratio. Given the SME Lending Adjustment (SMELA) will apply as a reduction to Pillar 2A and as such apply to the capital stack in the same percentages, the CET1 ratio increase in Pillar 1 requirements will only be partially offset by a 56.25% reduction in Pillar 2A. This is inconsistent with the way the support factor would have applied to capital requirements. We recommend that the calculation methodology is refined to remove this inconsistency, for example, the SMELA adjustment could be applied 100% against CET1 (i.e. Pillar 2A and then Buffers).

2.9 Stress testing

2.10 For credit risk, stress testing forms an important part of the PRA’s expectations of how firms should assess their Pillar 2A requirements. However, for smaller growing banks, stress testing and scenario development from first principles can prove time-consuming, resource intensive and challenging. Our members would therefore welcome fuller guidance on the approach the PRA expects smaller firms to adopt.

2.11 More specifically:

(a) Members would appreciate further guidance on how the P2A credit stress testing scenarios should be calibrated to ensure industry wide consistency. CP12/25 guidance is limited to:

    (i) Firms “should design their own scenarios through exploring high-severity tail events over a 12-month horizon”; and

    (ii) “Firms should ensure their own credit scenarios are more severe than the historical average peak-to-trough change in  key macroeconomic scenario variables in Bank Capital Stress Tests or equivalent benchmark scenarios published by the PRA.”

The proposed amendments to SS31/15 however provide little practical guidance as to how these scenarios should be designed or calibrated to ensure a consistent approach across firms. For example, one firm may include a 12-month stress which is benchmarked against Year 1 of the Bank Capital Stress Tests, adding some severity to create a plausible 12-month tail event, while another firm may benchmark against the cumulative 2-3-year peak to trough stress period. To ensure a consistent approach, we would recommend that the PRA publish a Pillar 2A scenario which firms can use as a starting point for the development of their own scenarios, similar to the current approach used for Pillar 2B stress testing.

(b) The current proposals do not explain how stress tests may demonstrate that a Pillar 2A credit risk add-on is not required. Even if the stress test outcome shows that P1 capital is sufficient, Paragraph 2.58 of the consultation seems to imply that a Pillar 2A credit risk add-on will always be required, despite the greater risk sensitivity of credit risk RWA under Basel 3.1. This means that firms that do not currently have a credit risk Pillar 2A add-on will now be required to include one, even if it is unnecessary.

(c) The proposals double count credit concentration risk. There is an automatic mid-range add-on of about 1.3% for concentration risk for UK only lenders. The proposed Pillar 2A credit stress testing approach then covers this same geographic credit risk for UK-focused banks because the PRA requires credit stress scenarios to reflect an even more severe UK macroeconomics stress than the Bank of England’s scenarios, with the stress period compressed to 12 months from three to five years (UK exposures are also subject to the Countercyclical Capital Buffer whose capital requirement currently stands at 2% of UK RWA in Common Equity Tier 1).

2.12 The PRA must remove the geographic concentration risk requirement, to avoid double counting of Pillar 2A capital requirements for UK macroeconomic stress. We also recommend the PRA publish a Pillar 2A credit scenario to ensure a consistency in design and severity of firm scenarios.

2.13 Unconditionally cancellable commitments

2.14 The proposed calibration of the conversion factor for ‘unconditionally cancellable commitments’ (UCCs) is based on “qualifying revolving exposures,” which are defined as exposures to individuals. As a result, this is unlikely to be appropriate for SMEs.

2.15 The current proposals will increase capital requirements on UCCs for SME exposures such as undrawn overdrafts. This is likely to reduce the availability of working capital funding to SMEs and hamper growth of the UK economy. It is noted that SME overdrafts accounted for 31% of SME bank lending in 1998 but have declined to just 5% today[1], a trend that is likely to continue under this proposal.

2.16 Given their relative lack of historical data compared to incumbents, it will be more      difficult for challenger banks to provide the supporting data to enable them to use the 10% conversion factor for UCCs (rather than the prescribed conversion factor of 20%). The risk is that challenger banks will be required to hold more capital than incumbents for similar risk.

2.17 Given the importance of the challenger bank credit provision to SMEs, we recommend that challenger banks be allowed to apply a conversion factor of 10% for SME UCCs unless there are unusual circumstances. In addition, any proposed change should consider the economic impact of a likely further reduction in working capital availability to SMEs, particularly considering the PRA’s secondary competitiveness and growth objective.

3. Operational Risk

3.1 The PRA has clarified that it will consider the following factors when reviewing a firm’s operational risk assessment:

    • The firm’s business model and its exposure to operational risk;
    • The firm’s analysis in its Internal Capital Adequacy Assessment Process (ICAAP), with a focus on scenario analysis;
    • The quality of the firm’s own Pillar 2A assessment, including appropriateness and robustness;
    • Any insights gathered through engagement with the firm; and
    • Peer group comparison.

3.2 This is helpful in providing clarity on what the PRA considers when setting Pillar 2A, but it does not provide any further transparency about how PRA applies judgment on Pillar 2A. This is the main difficulty our members face, making it difficult for firms to either understand or address the PRA’s concerns. To address this gap, we recommend that the PRA provide greater transparency on the calibration of how the factors set out drive its decisions on setting Pillar 2A for operational risk.

3.3 We also recommend that the term ‘significant firm’ is not used to define the scope of assessment and is replaced by an unambiguous term, such as the Potential Impact Categories, as set out in the PRA’s approach to supervision.

3.4 In particular:

(a) We suggest the PRA provide guidance on how firms should aggregate stress test scenarios to arrive at an appropriate capital requirement for operational risk. This will help to improve firms’ analysis, deliver consistency and facilitate PRA review.

(b) Operational loss events are often high-impact and low-frequency events, for which challenger banks typically have little internal data. For non-conduct risks, the PRA refers to using a Pareto distribution to calibrate operational risk capital for each Basel event type, using a predetermined shape parameter. We propose the PRA disclose these distributions to firms to enable smaller firms to make use of the PRA’s loss data.

(c) We recommend that the PRA clarifies how conduct risk should be treated in Pillar 2A scenario analysis to avoid double counting in idiosyncratic stress testing. This would enable firms to have more confidence in their assertions that certain risks should be capitalised in going and gone concern capital.

4. Supervisory review and evaluation process

4.1 We recommend that the PRA reconsider its approach to the frequency of its SREP for challenger banks. While we appreciate that the PRA adopts a proportionate approach that links the frequency and intensity of the SREP to firms’ scale and complexity, for smaller, growing firms, this means one every three to five years. For growing firms that are evolving rapidly, there are clear benefits to the regulator and the firm of more frequent SREPs.

4.2 In conjunction with the recently announced PRA Scale-Up Unit, we therefore recommend the PRA introduce a ‘fast-growing firm SREP’ that would provide more frequent review that would be welcomed. This would also help further embed the ICAAP in firms’ internal management processes and serve to make the SREP better reflective of the rapidly evolving position of a fast-growing firm and therefore more effective for smaller firms and supervisors.  

5. Phase 2 of the Pillar 2A review

5.1 We would welcome clarity on the scope of the next phase of the Pillar 2A review, such as whether it will seek to revisit credit and operational risk.

5.2 In particular, we would like more clarity on Swap Spread Risk capitalisation and which parts of the Interest Rate Risk in the Banking Book (IRRBB) policy are applicable to a mid-sized firm as opposed to a Category 1 firm.

5.3 We would also welcome more clarity from the PRA on the impact on non-UK exposures and what the add-ons would be for them.

[ENDS]


[1] Allica Bank, Rebooting SME Finance to Unlock Growth. From Overdrafts to Obstacles: A long run analysis of SME Finance trends and policy levers. See here: https://www.allica.bank/hubfs/Allica%20Bank%20%E2%80%93%20Rebooting%20SME%20Finance%20report%20(2025).pdf 

load more
0