Ofcom call for evidence “Third phase of online safety regulation” Innovate Finance response
Innovate Finance welcomes the opportunity to respond to Ofcom’s call for evidence on the Third phase of online safety regulation. While not the sole area of interest in our response, we primarily focus on Chapter 7 of the call for evidence which covers fraudulent advertising because this issue relates to our work on the wider regulatory efforts to combat fraud. We see the introduction of the Online Safety Act 2023 as an important contribution to the holistic response needed to tackle fraud, given the scale and complexity of the challenge. Hence, while we acknowledge the range of issues that Ofcom seeks to understand through this call for evidence, we limit our response to issues related to fraud.
We also recognise the constraints that Ofcom faces because it is bound by the parameters set by the Online Safety Act in relation to fraudulent advertising. Chapter 7 focuses on paid-for advertising, rather than user-generated content, such as listings on peer-to-peer online marketplaces, which can be deemed “advertising”. We acknowledge this but still consider it important to highlight both forms of advertising.
Our response thus addresses both user-generated content and paid-for advertisements. Nevertheless, we focus more on the former given that fraudulent listings on online peer-to-peer marketplaces are a significant contributor of payments fraud. To avoid confusion, we make the distinction between user-generated content and paid-for advertisements throughout our response.
We would summarise our views as follows:
- Most prevalent kind of fraudulent advertising and its harms: We once again present data to Ofcom that the most common form of authorised push payment (APP) fraud are those related to illegal financial promotions which encompasses online shopping scams (e.g. fraudulent listings on Facebook Marketplace) and investment scams. Evidence also shows that Meta is the single largest source of fraud origination. Fraudulent advertising not only leads to financial and emotional distress for victims, but could also lead to the distrust of digital payment options. This will damage the UK’s international competitiveness in the FinTech and financial services sector.
- User identity verification duties: Online peer-to-peer marketplaces like Facebook Marketplace are a particular challenge due to the lack of minimum identity verification for potential sellers. We recommend that Ofcom sets out minimum verification rules for both identity and listings that large user-to-user services must conduct. This will clamp down on anonymity, making it more difficult for fraudsters to list fake goods with impunity, thereby cutting down on purchase scams.
- Best practice for advertising onboarding and verification: While online service providers such as Meta and Google both have rules requiring firms to be authorised by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) before launching financial services advertisements on their platforms, Meta’s choice of wording in its rules is more ambiguous than Google’s, which we regard as a best practice across the sector. As a best practice, we encourage Ofcom to make it a norm that advertisers must be authorised by the FCA, and such language is reflected in the terms and conditions of online platforms.
- Clearer reporting and complaints processes: More clarity on reporting and complaints processes for online peer-to-peer marketplaces should be given to users from the outset. For example, it is not immediately clear on Facebook Marketplace’s support pages on what the process of reporting fraudulent advertised products is because users will only know the steps involved once they begin the process of filing a report. A lack of clarity from the outset could lead to a lack of awareness or trust in reporting systems which further contributes to the under-reporting of fraud. We call on Ofcom to require online to increase clarity on reporting processes to enhance transparency, accessibility, ease of use and users’ awareness which will empower victims.
- Less rigid reporting mechanisms: Peer-to-peer online marketplaces such as Facebook Marketplace have rigid approaches to reporting. Victims are expected to file reports of scams themselves or seek help from others to do so. Moreover, reports on Facebook Marketplace can only be processed if they are made through the report link that accompanies every listing. This fails to take into account the reality that victims might be blocked by the scammer or that the listing is removed as soon as the scam is completed, which makes locating the fraudulent listing and scammer difficult. We recommend that 2 Ofcom encourage online service providers to take a less rigid approach to reporting by committing to investigate complaints even without links and screenshots.

