Consultation Paper (CP24/2) Our Enforcement Guide and publicising enforcement investigations – a new approach Innovate Finance response

29th April 2024 | Consultation

 

About Innovate Finance

Innovate Finance is the independent industry body that represents and advances the global FinTech community in the UK. Innovate Finance’s mission is to accelerate the UK's leading role in the financial services sector by directly supporting the next generation of technology-led innovators to create a more inclusive, more democratic, and more effective financial services sector that works better for everyone.

The UK FinTech sector encompasses businesses from seed-stage start-ups to global financial institutions, illustrating the change that is occurring across the financial services industry. Since its inception in the era following the Global Financial Crisis of 2008, FinTech has been synonymous with delivering transparency, innovation and inclusivity to financial services. As well as creating new businesses and new jobs, it has fundamentally changed how consumers and businesses access finance. When engaging the government, we aim to reflect the UK FinTech ecosystem and specifically the needs of start-ups, scale-ups and high growth enterprises. 

Question 1: Do you agree with our proposal to announce our investigations, including the names of the subjects, and publish updates on those investigations, when in the public interest? Please give reasons for your answer.

We do not agree with the FCA’s proposed approach to announce investigations as outlined in the consultation paper. We would encourage the FCA to drop the plan to name firms or individuals and propose alternative ways of improving transparency as part of its enforcement work. While we recognise the important role enforcement plays, our members feel the approach outlined in the consultation paper could have significant negative impacts on the success of the UK FinTech sector, and put it at a competitive disadvantage internationally. 

Given the potential impact of the proposals, it is disappointing to read only a single reference to the impact on the FCA’s secondary objective of advancing the international competitiveness of the UK economy and its growth in the medium to long-term, saying “we consider our proposed changes are compatible”. Given the strength of the market reaction to the proposals our members do not believe it is credible or based on evidence for the FCA to say the proposals are compatible with the FCA’s new secondary objectives. Moreover, the lack of any detailed explanation on this point in the consultation paper is disappointing.

Moreover, we are not aware of any other G7 country that currently takes the approach on enforcement that the FCA is proposing, making the UK an international outlier. This would have real consequences and will dissuade investors from considering the UK in future, diminishing its attractiveness to business. This issue is especially acute for the FinTech sector given the important role that funding plays to support the growth of firms from an early stage. Each year we publish an Investment Landscape report for FinTech, and our data for 2023 revealed that the UK is still the second largest recipient of investment behind the United States. One of the key reasons the UK has established its global position is because of the regulatory environment and the stability and predictability that allows investors to make long-term investments. In conversations with our community there is already considerable unrest that the new enforcement proposals would make the UK a less attractive environment for FinTech funding. 

Given that the majority of enforcement cases end with no action being taken, this means that a majority of firms and/or individuals are found not to have committed any wrongdoing. However, the naming of firms as being under investigation will undoubtedly influence the behaviour of consumers who, for example, might choose to withdraw their money or close their investment account. This would have an even greater impact on a smaller firm seeking to scale and achieve commercial viability. It is highly likely that some 3rd party suppliers to smaller firms will withdraw their services as a result of the publication of an ongoing investigation, for example, payment services, custody services, banking services, which will threaten the viability of the firm. What broker or financial adviser is going to recommend to a client to deal with a firm which is under an investigation? Equally, there are real potential reputational issues for firms or individuals named, even in the event they are found to have not committed any wrongdoing, as the accusation could receive considerable public and media interest when announced.

Our members also have serious concerns over the proposed public interest framework, used to inform decisions on whether to make a public announcement. It is not clear how these factors would be weighted or how a consistent approach would be applied which could lead to inconsistent outcomes. Some of the factors are so broad and high level it is difficult to understand how they could be used in a way that would establish trust and credibility. A real risk is that they end up being subjective criteria used on a case by case basis which harms the credibility of the new approach.

We are strongly of the view that improved transparency, educating the sector on enforcement issues, and reducing the time to conclude cases could be achieved within the current framework and without the need to name firms. For example, by establishing an ‘enforcement watch’ that details concerns and trends, but stops short of naming firms publicly. By proceeding with the proposals as they stand, the FCA risks undermining its reputation as cases where firms have been named end without action. This is something that should be avoided.

load more
0